
In fourth grade, I had a teacher that was passionate about environmentalism — she talked about recycling, about turning lights off, about just not buying things if we didn’t really need them, about species & rainforests, floods & droughts. It’s forty years later, and we need the same lessons, we need to learn & act.
We’ve had nonfiction works galore to persuade us, documentaries & journalism of all types. Several novels that fall under the (new to me) subgenre Climate Fiction, or Cli-Fi — that is, fiction that deals with the effects of climate change on human society. From head-on nature-as-protagonist stories like Richard Powers’ The Overstory to more subtle horror stories about a world mid-crumble like Rumaan Alam’s Leave the World Behind. Now, one of the best I’ve read.
In Eleutheria debut novelist Allegra Hyde tells a provocative & personal, imaginative & realistic story of the challenges & consequences of the Anthropocene era. The novel’s two questions are big ones: “What hath man wrought?” and “What now?”
Hyde writes with historical, sociological, and emotional precision all centered on a well-meaning young idealistic protagonist Willa Marks. Homeschooled by environmentalist preppers, Willa becomes drawn to a utopian project called Camp Hope – a carbon negative sustainable compound in the hurricane-battered Bahamas poised to be an example for how to survive our environmental choices.
In Eleutheria Hyde crafts believable near-future realities (a Green Republican party, Freegan-fueled riots in Cambridge) and sobering actual realities (scholarship weaponized by the eleite, mass natural catastrophes, the consequences of imperialism and consumerism) in a suspenseful and readable blend of a coming-of-age and a falling-out-of-idealism stories. But it’s not all Willa’s story — her story fits into so much more.
In weaving foils & historical echoes, Hyde demonstrates what’s at stake, who benefits, and how we are led astray: from social media to 17th-century history, from global politics to campus politics, from eros to gaia. The last chapter was riveting & moving – as Daniel Peña said in a recent Zoom with Hyde, I don’t think I’ve read a better ending to a novel in a long time.
You can buy Eleutheria here, and you can read about other stuff I’ve read here.
8 responses to “i read eleutheria.”
I will stay that Leave the World Behind freaked me out. I still shudder when I think about the description of the sound that they heard…more than once. This sounds like something I might read…maybe. Millet’s The Children’s Bible is another stunning cautionary tale. (I’ll have to see if you have it reviewed. Your reading life is staggering, I’ll confess!)
LikeLike
I haven’t read the one you’re talking about. Eleutheria will be on some top ten lists this year, so I wanted to be one of the cool kids that read it early 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you for this thoughtful book review. I liked how you introduced it with a story about your fourth grade teacher.
LikeLike
Thanks for reading! 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you for posting a review of a genre I haven’t had experience reading. I’ll save this one for summer break where I can take my time with it. I was reading quite a bit of YA dystopia a while back and needed a break from it. A little too close to reality sometimes. Saving your post for future reference.
LikeLike
It is *quite* close to reality — as is the Ukrainian novel Grey Bees, which I reviewed a week ago. Both are great, but I feel ya about knowing when you can take on a tough subject
LikeLike
I read Overstory and was struck by the life underneath our feet. The communication of trees over and under the surface where we live. Thanks for this review!
LikeLike
Hyde’s isn’t near as scientific as Powers’s novel — but then again, whose is? 🙂
LikeLike